A tom boy's transition

and boy, do I have some stories to tell

  • This September marks the 25th anniversary of coming out as a lesbian, at the ripe age of 19; it just so happens to fall in the same month of my birthday too, which is another reason to celebrate this time of year! For the first time in my life, I really do feel like celebrating this year, versus just simply acknowledging the day I was born. Over the course of the last 18 months, I have completely changed my life and finally built the life I was finally meant to lead. I left my toxic marriage of almost 10 years, moved to a brand new city, alone, and finally started living again. I started taking improv classes at The Second City, got back to the gym, and landed the job of a lifetime with the Chicago Cubs. So why was it with all of those incredible achievement was I still miserable? And by miserable, I mean still having reoccurring thoughts of self-harm despite being properly monitored and medicated by doctors and therapists for several years leading up to this point in time. 

    In order to talk about today, I have to talk about how I got here. First of all, I always hated my government name: Julie, and to boot, my middle name: Ann. Most kids growing up in the 80s and 90s knew that hearing your first and middle name together meant you were in BIG trouble, so needless to say, I heard that combo yelled ALOT. I never really felt like a “Julie” and I would actively tell that to new people I would meet during introductions, but I couldn’t actually explain it beyond “I just don’t feel like it fits who I am.” So I often settled for whatever anyone wanted to call me, minus Julie Ann. Gross.

    One name I always felt comfortable with and rightfully called was Jules – it’s the commonplace nickname most family and friends of a “Julie” would use, but in my life, it felt especially correct and fitting. Many variations of Jules would make their way in to my life, like: JuJu, Ju, JuJuBeans, Juji (pronounced JOO-JEE) and even varied spelling and pronunciation as Julis (pronounced JOO-LISS). Needless to say, I preferred to be called anything BUT Julie. 

    Looking back now, it’s practically laughable how uncomfortable my entire existence has been by trying to fit in to a patriarchal society, where I felt like I had to choose to follow a binary gender construct. Given my upbringing, my lack of knowledge and understanding around gender identities, and just close-mindedness in general, I had no idea what the term non-binary even meant, but once I did, it perfectly identified the way I’d felt since childhood…neither girl nor boy.

    It really wasn’t even until this past January, when I was struggling with the original concept of my blog, The Dysfunctional Dyke that I hit a metaphoric wall. 

    I was laying in bed, writing about my high school girl crush and how it ultimately led to my coming out story, lesbian edition. It made me finally acknowledge that while I originally came out as a lesbian, in response to my same-sex attraction to women, that I could also find myself attracted to men(gasp!) Now, I grew up in the days were the acronym for us homos was GLBT, and while it has rightfully evolved to something more in today’s world, I’m still a boomer when it comes to learning the terminologies of it all. The best way to describe my attraction to people these days is simply “hearts, not parts.” But I digress.

    From what I can recall, there was no lightbulb that went off over my head or a bolt of lightning that struck me, like in cartoons, but it was in that moment I knew I could no longer keep living my life the way it had been to this point; I wanted my story to continue, unlike in years past when I just wanted it all to end. 

    I remember laying there in bed, with my cat, Tezzie, curled up next to me when I felt an immense weight slowly lift from my entire soul. Similar to the night I signed my lease on my apartment in Chicago, solidifying the fact that my broken marriage would soon end, I sobbed uncontrollably. Maybe it was the grief of a life I was losing, or the time I felt like I had lost to those years of my emotional imprisonment, but there was more of a sense of relief than anything. 

    As a recovering pathological people pleaser, I spent far too long worrying about what others would say or think versus how I needed to live my OWN life. In reflection of my inner turmoil, specifically my depression and anxiety, it disappeared almost overnight, like an overpowering weight had finally been lifted. Then, in March of this year, I began HRT (hormone replacement therapy) to further my gender-affirming care. At that time, I had no idea how greatly it would impact and improve my life, both physically and mentally. 

    To be clear, EVERYONE should have access to gender-affirming care, because just like our fingerprints, we all have a uniqueness to ourselves, and it is not simply a trans issue. In my journey back to physical fitness over the last four years, I was reminded that our mental fitness is just as vital to our health and success. While everyone’s story has its own origin, I personally don’t look at my gender-affirming care as a way to transition to a man, but simply have my outward appearance reflect my inner-self. Not only am I gaining a deeper voice, darkening, thicker body hair, and a more defined muscle mass, but I’m finally able to see the person who has been just beneath the surface this whole time.

    I don’t wish that I was born and raised as a boy, and I’ll even take it a step further by saying I embrace being “AFAB” or “Assigned Female At Birth” because my personal experience is not one of regret, but rather of gratitude. I wouldn’t be the same open-minded, empathetic, kind-hearted person that am if I had been raised as a boy in the 80s and 90s. You might be thinking that’s extremely narrow-minded and judgmental, but for someone who was conditioned to believe that women are secondary to men, in work, at home, in life, I can assure you that would have been my fate. I was raised to believe that feminists are ugly, mean, wretched, lonely cat-hoarding old maids who hate men. Ironically enough, having embraced myself in the last year, I am a bigger feminist now than ever before, and also, cat ladies are hot af; I have far more to say about toxic masculinity, but that post is for another day.

    I’ve spent years in therapy, and thousands of dollars to be reassured by medical professionals that my feelings and identity are valid, knowing now that I’ve spent far too long thinking something was inherently wrong with me. Today, I celebrate the life I’m choosing, yes CHOOSING, to lead. I used to be afraid of being labeled as “choosing” to live a certain way, when really life is all about making choices, and this is the most important one I’ve made to date. Today, I am reaffirming my choice to be here, fully and authentically, to celebrate the 44 years I’ve been given to this point, and to make the most of the years ahead of me. 

    The human body is simply a vessel that our souls are carried by here on this planet – I just shipped in the wrong box – (lesbian joke inferred, btw). So while my appearance will continue to evolve, I’m still the same person you’ve grown to love, adore and wish you could be when you grow up. But most importantly, at the end of the day, I know the person looking back at me in the mirror and it’s just Jules. 🙂

  • At the end of last year, I finally decided I was going to take the leap and start the blog I had talked about creating for the last several years. So I dug out my notes, got to writing, and even came up with the catchy name- The Dysfunctional Dyke– I even purchased the domain…oops. But I knew it was more than my attention deficit that was holding me back from documenting my truth – my absolute truth- and I knew I couldn’t continue with the selected title to carry my story. I began to finally sit with my uncomfortable realization that at 43 years of age, I needed to come out again. I figured I had so much fun the first time around, then why not, right?

    The first person I came out to was a counselor my sophomore year of college. I can vaguely recall sitting across from an unremarkable man in a clinical setting but couldn’t tell you why or how I got there that particular day. All I know is that it was my first audible declaration of being queer, and while it was profound, it was otherwise unremarkable. Maybe it’s because since that day, I have had more conversations about justifying my existence to people than I care to count, but it’s no less than in the thousands at this point, and I’m exhausted.

    For years, I have shrunk, lessened and quieted myself for the comfort of others and I’m finally breaking free from that prison. For the first time in 43 years, I am standing up for myself, loving myself, and accepting myself for who I’ve always known is the real me. In my older, more rigid years I’ve come to joke that I never actually came out of the proverbial closet. Instead, it was everyone else who was so afraid, and hiding away from the truth that was hiding in plain sight.

    This blog is a deeply personal journey that exposes me to my core, both good and bad. It provides me an outlet to discuss and highlight the very moments that shaped me throughout my life, and how I have overcome grueling challenges to be where I am today. My expertise is limited to my unique experiences, but I do hope that through sharing my story that others can find inspiration, clarity, or support for themselves too. Living the last 43 years as a woman, and over half of that as a lesbian, my life has incorporated a bountiful array of trauma, heartbreak, and struggles that not even the best Hollywood script writers could fathom.

    I am here to share my countless stories with truth, dignity, intimacy, humor and occasional vulgarity. From surviving an abusive childhood to leveling up after divorce and starting a new life, and to everywhere in between, my story is ready to be told. So no matter which era of my life you entered, you’re here for the best one yet. I cannot wait to revisit it all and share it with you here.

    Thanks for coming along for the ride…(that’s what she said)

  • One of the first entries I knew that I wanted to share was what it was like growing up queer. Being raised in a traditional, conservative, devoutly Catholic household, acting or presenting like anything other than those very things was not optional. Since childhood, my best friends in school had always been boys. I attended catholic grade school where, by the time I graduated, I was one of five students in my class, total, yes TOTAL. Our school was so small that both the fifth and sixth grades shared a classroom as well as the seventh and eighth grades. Even with combined classrooms, I always preferred befriending the boys, and they welcomed me with open arms.

    Everyday at lunch we would sit at the same end of the table in the cafeteria and talk about our beloved sports teams or the latest cheat codes available for our favorite video games. Afterwards, at recess, we would sit on the sidewalk and bond over an intense chess match, while the girls picked flowers and talked about their boyfriends (their boyfriends went to the public schools.) 

    I was considered one of the more athletic kids in school, which is not a braggadocios statement amongst a combined one-dozen students, but I was always the first one to be picked for a sport (that’s if I wasn’t already one of the designated team captains.) Not too shabby for a girl, right? Even for the two boys who were in my class, they knew I could kick their asses, so it was in their best interest to keep me close and likely why they preferred to play chess with me.

    When it came to our school dances (combined with other schools, for obvious reasons) I preferred to stand and talk to the guys rather than dance with my hands on their bodies with our faces merely inches apart (gross). I feel like my classmates treated me like I was just one of the boys, outside from using the pink colored bathrooms versus the blue ones (yes they really were those colors) Just outside of those very bathrooms, right next to the water fountain was where I heard my first homophobic slur: GAY!

    “You’re GAY!” I heard one of the prepubescent boys yell in another’s face. “NO, YOU’RE GAY!” the other one yelled back at him.

    Nothing like a quality, catholic education, amarite?

    That night I went home, like any sheltered middle school kid in the mid-nineties without Google did, and asked my parents what the word “gay” meant. They told me it was just another word for “happy” which really wasn’t a lie, but I called bullshit when I said those boys definitely had a tone that wasn’t accusing either one of happiness. It was chalked up to “boys will be boys” and it was left at that. Needless to say, the next time the word gay came out of my mouth in front of my parents, they knew I didn’t mean happy either, so I guess I got even? Alas, that fun story/blog post will be coming shortly…

    Ok, now back to me being a gay kid…

    When summertime rolled around, I would spend hours in our side yard, practicing my knuckleball and fastball deliveries, with a scoop of big league chew or a folded up fruit roll up in my mouth to mimic the big-leaguers’ use of chewing tobacco. (I remember the 90s baseball bros always had wads of chew in their cheeks, like good ole Lenny Dykstra.) So while I was trying to blow my arm out while on a sugar high, I felt no worries in my little boyish brain on those summer days.

    Meanwhile, my one and older sister was busy nearby on her lounge chair, sunbathing and reading the latest Stephen King novel. She would occasionally humor me and come catch my 25mph fastball instead of me launching it into the brick and mortar of our childhood home. I was convinced, even as a little girl, that I could pitch like Greg Maddux someday or hit homers out of Wrigley Field like Sammy Sosa. But those dreams eventually died in that side yard, when I was reminded that girls played softball, and that baseball was only for boys, which made me both mad and sad. Just like Tom Hanks famously said in “A League of Their Own” though “there’s no crying in baseball.” So I guess since boys aren’t allowed to cry, that actually all checks out.

    Tale as old as time – “boys do this” and “girls do that”

    Why?

    Well, because we said so, that’s why!

    OH, okay.

    So, I’ll fast forward like 35 years, and guess what, baseball is actually for everyone. And I’m convinced that while my old classmates can probably beat me in chess today, I can definitely still kick their asses.

    – J